The Harvard Lawyer vs the Bad Boy from the Bronx: Explaining the Political Performance Gaps between Rubén Blades and Willie Colón
A Genre Approach to Celebrity Politics pp 75-96 | Cite as
Abstract
Rubén Blades and Willie Colón are commonly regarded as the two undisputed salsa music giants. Their joint album Siembra from 1978 is considered a masterpiece of the genre, highly praised by critics for its hard-hitting lyrics and sophisticated musical arrangements. Siembra was also a best-selling album for a salsa record, with 3 million copies sold around the world and several hits, such as ‘Pedro Navaja’, ‘Plastico’, and ‘Buscando Guayaba’, which became true salsa classics.1 Once their successful artistic partnership ended, the musical career of these two great musicians took a very dissimilar path. Rubén Blades became a major international pop icon, famous for his performances as a Hollywood actor as well, whereas Willie Colón remained a relatively obscure figure within the American musical scene, confined mainly to salsa music and Hispanic listeners. In addition to their artistic activities, both Blades and Colón had dabbled in professional politics, again with very disparate results. Rubén Blades became a major political figure in Panama, his native country, first as a presidential candidate and later as Minister of Tourism; Willie Colón failed in his endeavour to become a candidate for the US Congress, and his political activity was restricted to serving as advisor to New York City’s mayor Michael Bloomberg, representing the local Puerto Rican community.
Keywords
Latin American Country Presidential Candidate Music Industry Political Performance Artistic CareerPreview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Notes
- D. M. Randel (1991) ‘Crossing Over with Rubén Blades’, Journal of the American Musicological Society, 44(2), 301–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- R. Rosario (1979) ‘Salsero with a Message’, Nuestro, 56–8.Google Scholar
- According to Blades, Noriega plotted against his father because he disapproved of his proximity to General Omar Torrijos, Panama’s leader in 1969–81. See D. Manrique (29 August 2002) ‘Rubén Blades, El Salsero de Hollywood’, El Pais (Spain), retrieved from: <http://elpais.com/diario/2002/08/29/revistaverano/1030572001_850215.html>. In another version, Blades’ father was closely connected to the circles that had plotted against Torrijos, but although he was not personally involved in the coup, he was forced to go into exile. SeeGoogle Scholar
- J. A. Moreno-Velazquez (14 April 2000) ‘Rubén Blades, un hombre en tiempo por los tiempos’, El Diario La Prensa (New York), p. 28. for Noriega’s status as a CIA agent, see Notes 191Google Scholar
- P. D. Scott and J. Marshall (1998) Cocaine Politics: Drugs, Armies, and the CIA in Central America (Berkeley: University of California Press).Google Scholar
- R. Parker (1985) ‘The Vision of Rubén Blades: Panama’s Salsa King Finds New Worlds to Conquer’, Americas, 37, 15–19.Google Scholar
- P. Brittmarie Janson (1987) ‘Political Facets of Salsa’, Popular Music, 6(2), 149–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- P. Manuel (1991) ‘Latin Music in the United States: Salsa and the Mass Media’, Journal of Communication, 41(1), 104–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- L. S. Gonzalez (1999) ‘Reclaiming Salsa’, Cultural Studies, 13(2), 237–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- D. Mato (1998) ‘On the Making of Transnational Identities in the Age of Globalization: the US Latina/o-“Latin” American case’, Cultural Studies, 12(4), 598–620.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- W. Colón and R. Blades (1978) Siembra [LP] (New York: Fania Records).Google Scholar
- (2 February 1993) ‘Pablo Milanes and Rubén Blades Dispute Over Castro’, New York Transfer News, retrieved from: <www.maestravida.com/library/NYTransferNewsRBMilanes1993.rtf>.
- Willie Colón’s parents were born in the United States to Puerto Rican parents. Tito Puente, another leading salsa and latin jazz musician, was born in Puerto Rico but moved to New York with his family at a very early age. See E. Morales (2003) ‘The Story of Nuyorican Salsa’, in his book The Latin Beat: the Rhythms and Roots of Latin Music from Bossa Nova to Salsa and Beyond (Cambridge, MA: Da Capo Press, Perseus Books), pp. 55–93.Google Scholar
- G. Lim (July 1988) ‘Panamanian Pandemonium: Rubén Blades: Musician, Actor, Activist’, LA Style, retrieved from: <www.maestravida.com/library/PanamanianPandemonium1988.doc>;Google Scholar
- G. Rivera (1999) ‘Q&A: a Conversation With Rubén Blades’, Jazz Conclave, retrieved from: <http://www.jazzconclave.com/i-room/blades.html>.Google Scholar
- See R. Grosfoguel (1999) ‘Puerto Ricans in the USA: a Comparative Approach’, Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 25(2), 233–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- R. Palmer (4 April 1984) ‘The Pop Life: Rubén Blades’s Salsa’, New York Times, retrieved from: <http://www.nytimes.com/1984/04/04/arts/the-pop-life-ruben-blades-s-salsa.html>;Google Scholar
- D. Shewey (7 June 1984) ‘Buscando America’, Rolling Stone Magazine, p. 47;Google Scholar
- P. Hamill (19 August 1985) ‘Hey It’s Rubén Blades: a Latin Star makes his Move’, New York Magazine, pp. 42–9;Google Scholar
- P. McGilligan (September 1986) ‘The Ten Sexiest Men in America’, Playgirl, pp. 39–43;Google Scholar
- D. Fricke (23 April 1987) ‘Rubén Blades’s Latin Revolution’, Rolling Stone Magazine, pp. 36–42.Google Scholar
- E. Lopetegui (12 September 1993) ‘From Pop to Populism: Rubén Blades’s Music is Filled with Messages of Social Justice’, Los Angeles Times, p. 5.Google Scholar
- N. Beausoleil (1994) ‘Make-up in Everyday Life: an Inquiry into the Practices of Urban American Women of Diverse Backgrounds’, in N. Sault (ed.) Many Mirrors: Body Image and Social Relations (New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers), pp. 33–57.Google Scholar
- D. Kellner (1996) ‘Sports, Media Culture and Race: Some Reflections on Michael Jordan’, Sociology of Sport Journal, 13(4), 458–68;Google Scholar
- M. Lafrance and G. Rail (2001) ‘Excursions into Otherness: Understanding Dennis Rodman and the Limits of Subversive Agency’, in D. L. Andrews and S. J. Jackson (eds) Sport Stars: the Cultural Politics of Sporting Celebrity (London: Routledge), pp. 36–50.Google Scholar
- M. Weber (1968) On Charisma and Institution Building, Selected Papers, edited with an introduction by S. N. Eisenstadt (Chicago: University of Chicago Press), p. 21.Google Scholar
- M. Mehler (July 1984) ‘All Come to Look for America’, Record, p. 30;Google Scholar
- P. Span (5 November 1985) ‘Rubén Blades and the Spirit of Salsa: the Activist Singer-Turned-Actor Harbors No “Crossover Dreams” of His Own’, Washington Post, retrieved from: <www.maestravida.com/library/WashPostNov1985.rtf>.Google Scholar
- M. E. Scranton (1995) ‘Panama’s First Post-Transition Election’, Journal of Inter-American Studies and World Affairs, 37(1), 69–100.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- H. French (21 February 1994) ‘Panama Journal: Democracy at Work, Under Shadow of Dictators’, New York Times.Google Scholar
- On the social and cultural effect of the Reagan years, see M. P. Rogin (1987) Ronald Reagan, the Movie and Other Episodes in Political Demonology (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press);Google Scholar
- S. Jeffords (1994) Hard Bodies: Hollywood Masculinity in the Reagan Era (New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press).Google Scholar
- G. Garcia (1986) ‘Salsa’s Rubén Blades’, Interview (UK), pp. 209–11;Google Scholar
- L. Shaw (2013) ‘Interview with Rubén Blades’, in L. Shaw (ed.) Song and Social Change in Latin America (Plymouth, UK: Lexington Books), pp. 175–88.Google Scholar
- For some of the extremely positive profile articles on Blades in the mainstream American press during this period, see S. Holden (18 August 1985) ‘Rubén Blades Turns his Talents to Movies’, The New York Times, retrieved from: <http://www.nytimes.com/1985/08/18/arts/ruben-blades-turns-his-talents-to-movies.html>;Google Scholar
- B. Baroll (9 September 1985) ‘Salsa with a Political Spin’, Newsweek, p. 97;Google Scholar
- R. Harrington (29 November 1985) ‘Blades: Electric and Political’, Washington Post, retrieved from: <www.maestravida.com/library/WashPostNov291985.rtf>;Google Scholar
- S. Korones (May 1987) ‘Rubén Blades: Salsa Star with a Mission’, Cosmopolitan, p. 144;Google Scholar
- E. Fernandez ( January 1987) ‘Rubén Blades Crossover Dreaming’, Elle, pp. 51–2.Google Scholar
- E. Fernandez (September 1992) ‘La Encrucijada de Rubén Blades’, Mas, 4(5), 42–7.Google Scholar
- R. Sanchez (3 May 1994) ‘His Toughest Audience: With Five Days to go on the Presidential Campaign Trail, Rubén Blades is Discovering that Performing for a Sold-out Concert Hall is a Breeze Compared with Winning over Panamanians Hungry for Change’, Newsday, retrieved from: <http://search.proquest.com/docview/278823563?accountid=14765>.Google Scholar
- W. Sonnleitner (2010) ‘Las últimas elecciones en América Central:¿el quiebre de la tercera ola de democratizaciones?’, Foro Internacional, 808–49.Google Scholar
- A. Benjamin (23 February 2005) ‘Blades ya no canta’, La Prensa, retrieved from: <http://www.martesfinanciero.com/history/2005/02/22/Columnas/temadeportada.html>;Google Scholar
- S. Steward (26 July 2004) ‘Salsa with a Tang of Politics: He Has Run for the Presidency of Panama and Acted with Johnny Depp: Sue Steward Talks to Rubén Blades, the Salsero Superstar Like No Other’, The Daily Telegraph (UK), p. 17.Google Scholar
- J. Ibarz (14 September 2004) ‘La apuesta de Blades: “Dejo la música para hacer política”’, La Vanguardia, retrieved from: <http://www.martesfinanciero.com/history/2004/09/07/columna/actualidad/index.shtml>.Google Scholar
- A. Gurza (21 October 2006) ‘Window on Panama: Oft Considered a Detour on the Road to Somewhere Else, Panama Is So Much More. Business is Booming, Culture Abounds and the Music is Hot’, The Record (Kitchener, Ontario), retrieved from: <http://search.proquest.com/docview/267186847?accountid=14765>;Google Scholar
- I. Lakshmanan (22 January 2007) ‘In Panama City’s Old Quarter, a Rebirth Takes Place; American Helping Restore Buildings’, Boston Globe, retrieved from: <http://search.proquest.com/docview/405045674?accountid=14765>.Google Scholar
- A. Gurza (23 March 2007) ‘El Ministro Blades is Still the Salsa King’, Daily Press, retrieved from: <http://search.proquest.com/docview/343463826?accountid=14765>;Google Scholar
- C. Panky (25 January 2007) ‘Rubén Blades: Cuestiona el trato de “Fania All Star” a sus artistas’, La Prensa, p. 1.Google Scholar
- Lakshmanan (22 January 2007) ‘Rebirth’; A. Gurza (4 March 2007) ‘Ending his Tour of Political Duty; Ruben Blades Returns to Music after a Trying Mission in Panama’, Los Angeles Times, retrieved from: <http://search.proquest.com/docview/422122652?accountid=14765>.Google Scholar
- S. Pineda (2010) ‘Rubén Blades: política a son de Salsa’, Magis, Febrero-Marzo, 26–32.Google Scholar
- P. Yglesias (2005) Cocinando!: Fifty Years of Latin Album Cover Art (New York: Princeton Architectural Press), pp. 112–13.Google Scholar
- Fania artists have also mentioned Blaxploitation and Mafia movies of the period as influential in the design aesthetics of Fania Records’ cover art. See D. McCabe (director) (2011) ‘The Salsa Revolution’, Episode 2, Latin Music USA (TV series: PBS).Google Scholar
- D. McCabe (2011) ‘Politics, Society & Salsa: Rubén Blades & Willie Colón’, Episode 8, Latin Music USA (TV series: PBS).Google Scholar
- P. Bourdieu (1977) Outline of a Theory of Practice (translated by R. Nice) (Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press), p. 72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Colón’s work received poor reviews from American newspapers. See for example, J. O. N. Pareles (10 August 1986) ‘Pop: From Willie Colón, Pan American Music’, New York Times, retrieved from: <http://search.proquest.com/docview/425974183?accountid=14765>;Google Scholar
- P. Watrous (29 January 1990) ‘Reviews/Music: Salsa from Willie Colón and His Band’, The New York Times, retrieved from: <http://search.proquest.com/docview/427502736?accountid=14765>.Google Scholar
- E. Alvarez (13 December 1997) ‘Willie Colón, el actor’, Reforma (Mexico City), p. 12;Google Scholar
- C. Huerta (31 October 1999) ‘Willie Colónizara con su humorismo’, Reforma (Mexico City), p. 14.Google Scholar
- See for example, E. Morales (6 September 1994) ‘El Malo Wants the Bronx (and Westchester, Too)’, The Village Voice, p. 20;Google Scholar
- J. P. Fried (12 June 1994) ‘Neighborhood Report: North Bronx. Salsa King Aims for Congress’, The New York Times, retrieved from: <http://search.proquest.com/docview/429784529?accountid=14765>.Google Scholar
- Morales ‘El Malo Wants the Bronx’; M. Purdy (10 September 1994) ‘Geography, Not Ideology, Counts in District 17’, New York Times, retrieved from: <http://search.proquest.com/docview/429885017?accountid=14765>.Google Scholar
- M. Perez-Rivas (8 September 1994) ‘A Swan Song for the Incumbent? Colón and Engel Face Off’, Newsday, retrieved from: <http://search.proquest.com/docview/278845326?accountid=14765>.Google Scholar
- G. Borrero (8 August 2007) ‘Willie Colón insiste en su verdad’, El Diario La Prensa (New York), p. 4.Google Scholar
- G. Borrero (31 October 2005) ‘Tildan a Willie “vende patria”’, El Diario La Prensa (New York), p. 4Google Scholar
- D. Kirsten (28 November 2001) ‘Mayor Mike Might Add a Dash of Salsa’, The New York Post, p. 18;Google Scholar
- J. Rutenberg and D. Cardwell (17 September 2005) ‘As Ferrer Gains Support, Bloomberg Chooses to Withhold Some’, The New York Times, retrieved from: <http://search.proquest.com/docview/433159698?accountid=14765>.Google Scholar
- D. Seifman (24 March 2011) ‘Salsa Porn Rap’, New York Post, p. 13.Google Scholar
- (18 June 2013) ‘De segundón fracasado califica ministra de Venezuela a Willie Colón’, La Jornada (Mexico City), retrieved from: <http://www.jornada.unam.mx/2013/01/18/espectaculos/a09n2esp>; (12 April 2013) ‘Convocan protesta en San Juan contra Willie Colón por atacar a Nicolás Maduro’, EFE News Service (Madrid), retrieved from: <http://search.proquest.com/docview/1326213466?accountid=14765>.
- (10 April 2013) ‘Alejandro Sanz y Willie Colón envían mensajes de apoyo a Capriles’, EFE News Service (Madrid), retrieved from: <http://search.proquest.com/docview/1325151343?accountid=14765>.
- W. Neuman (11 April 2013) ‘Star Hurls Musical Barbs before Venezuela’s Vote’, The New York Times, retrieved from: <http://search.proquest.com/docview/1325256049?accountid=14765>.Google Scholar
- (9 April 2013) ‘Nicolás Maduro y Willie Colón enfrentados en “guerra musical”’, Panamericana (Peru), retrieved from: <http://www.panamericana.pe/internacionales/125244-nicolas-maduro-willie-Colón-enfrentados-guerramusical>; (9 April 2013) ‘Maduro responde con una canción a Willie Colón’, El Nuevo Dia (Puerto Rico), retrieved from: <http://www.elnuevodia.com/madurorespondeconunacancionawillieColón-1487006.html>.
- (20 January 2013) ‘Critica vocalista de Calle 13 comentarios de Willie Colón sobre Chávez’, NOTIMEX, retrieved from: <http://search.proquest.com/docview/1271596535?accountid=14765>.
- (17 September 2000) ‘Arremete Willie Colón contra los Estefan’, La Jornada (Mexico City), retrieved from: <http://www.jornada.unam.mx/2000/09/17/13an1esp.html>; (29 September 2000) ‘Willie Colón contra el Grammy: Pretenden enterrar el talento latino’, El Informador (Mexico), p. 7–D; (29 September 2001) ‘Denuncia censura’, Reforma (Mexico City), p. 14.
- J. Street (2002) ‘Bob, Bono and Tony B: the Popular Artist as Politician’, Media, Culture & Society, 24(3), 433–41.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Copyright information
Authors and Affiliations
- 1.Tel Aviv UniversityIsrael
-
-